* Neurofilament light (NfL) is a protein released when neurons are damaged and can be detected in the cerebrospinal fluid and blood. In ALS, higher NfL levels are generally associated with more rapid disease progression, at a group level. In clinical trials, NfL is evolving as a biomarker to help researchers understand whether a treatment may be reducing underlying motor neuron damage. NfL levels tend to rise during presymptomatic and early disease and then stabilize or plateau as the disease progresses, and when a substantial and sustained drop occurs with treatment, benchmarked at 30%, it is considered meaningful. Reductions of less than 30% are difficult to reliably attribute to an effect of the treatment.
- CNM-Au8, an investigational therapy developed by Clene, is made of gold nanocrystals designed to support the energy needs of motor neurons, the nerve cells affected by ALS. By improving cellular energy production and reducing stress on neurons, CNM-Au8 is theorized by Clene to help motor neurons function more effectively and survive longer, potentially slowing disease progression.
Clene has announced additional analyses of the data from CNM-Au8, previously investigated in a Phase 2 trial as part of the HEALEY ALS Platform Trial, and in a smaller Phase 2 trial called RESCUE-ALS.
Original data from the trials showed no benefit demonstrated by the study endpoints, including measures of function and disease progression. However, after the trial ended, Clene conducted additional exploratory analyses (called post-hoc analysis), looking more closely at specific groups of participants and other outcomes that were not part of the original main study. Clene reported that these analyses seemed to suggest some benefit for subgroups. Based on this, the company had announced that they intend to run a confirmatory Phase 3 trial (RESTORE-ALS).
Clene has now released additional analyses exploring neurofilament light chain (NfL)* in the past trials.
Results reported:
- Participants whose NfL levels remained stable or decreased while receiving CNM-Au8 appeared to have better outcomes, including slower disease progression and improved survival, compared to control participants.
- Conversely, participants whose NfL levels increased did not appear to experience the same benefit.
What needs to be considered:
- In group settings, stable NfL levels mean the disease is still progressing, which complicates these conclusions. Researchers generally look for a drop of at least 30% in NfL levels before considering it a meaningful sign that disease progression may be slowing, which was not shown by CNM-Au8.
- These findings come from analyses that were conducted after the trial had already ended and after the main results were known. In addition, Phase 2 trials typically do not include enough participants to provide definitive answers about a treatment’s effectiveness (they are often considered “underpowered”). Researchers also explored the data in several different ways, including examining participant subgroups and multiple outcomes. Together, these factors increase the possibility that positive findings may have occurred by chance rather than reflecting a true treatment effect. Although such analyses can provide useful clues about whether a treatment merits further study, they have historically not always held up in larger trials. As a result, these findings should be considered exploratory until they are confirmed in a future study.
Clene plans to include these analyses in its regulatory submission as it seeks accelerated approval for CNM-Au8 in the U.S. If the treatment advances to a Phase 3 trial, researchers will need to decide ahead of time which patient groups, biomarkers (such as NfL), and other outcomes they want to study. Including these questions in the original trial plan will help ensure the results provide more reliable answers.